logo
   Web Issue 3231 August 20 2008   
spacer
Bid to secure the future of rural hospitals is unveiled
HELEN PUTTICK, Health CorrespondentMay 14 2008

A plan to ensure the survival of Scotland's rural hospitals was published by the Scottish Government yesterday.

Health Secretary Nicola Sturgeon unveiled the strategy which tells patients living in the Highlands and islands the services they can expect on their doorstep. It promises the six rural general hospitals will be staffed by surgeons, physicians and anaesthetists.

Just five years ago the future of consultant cover at these smaller medical centres looked precarious. Threats to withdraw consultants from the Belford Hospital in Fort William and Lorn and Islands Hospital in Oban were fought off, but only after widespread public protest.

The new action plan has been welcomed, although doctors warned significant work is still needed on the ground.

MSP Jamie Stone also wanted more detail about the future of maternity services, expressing concern the plan could see this downgraded.

As well as Fort William and Oban, the rural general hospitals are based in Caithness, Orkney, Shetland and the Western Isles. Together they serve 150,000 people.

The Scottish Government states the core services which hospitals will provide include routine and emergency surgery, initial management of broken bones, management of acute medical conditions and midwife-led maternity care.

In a letter to Ms Sturgeon, Mr Stone vowed to fight tooth and nail for consultant-run maternity services. He said: "Twice now the consultant-led maternity service based in Caithness General Hospital in Wick has been considered for downgrading to a midwife-led service. Twice the local people have strenuously opposed this backward step, and twice they have won the argument."

However, others were more optimistic about the strategy.

David Sedgwick, consultant surgeon at the Belford, said he was delighted the team work which had gone into securing recognition for rural healthcare had now been endorsed.

He said: "I am confident the future of rural general hospitals has been placed on a very secure foundation and has a definite direction of travel. This contrasts to the situation five years ago."

He stressed it was important to ensure Scotland's medical education deaneries and health boards helped to train surgeons, physicians and anaesthetists to work in rural areas. The trend for doctors to specialise in narrower medical fields has been one of the key threats to rural hospitals, where clinicians require a wider range of skills.

Dr Andrew Buist, of the British Medical Association's Scottish Council, said the new report offered some solutions to the difficulties of delivering rural medicine. He added: "There is much more to do to transform this report into reality and I hope we can work with the Scottish Government and NHS boards to implement many of its recommendations."

The action plan includes training a new type of GP with extra skills in emergency medicine, ensuring rural hospitals have modern technology including CT scanning and better ambulance links. A pilot where consultants are flown to remote hospitals to transfer critically ill patients is planned.

Launching the report in Aviemore, Ms Sturgeon said: "After years of uncertainty, this report sets out a blueprint which will secure vital services for our rural communities."

Services provided

Gilbert Bain Hospital, Lerwick, Shetland
Has 26 acute surgical beds and 20 acute medical beds and a midwife-led labour suite.

Balfour Hospital, Kirkwall, Orkney
Has ward for medical and surgical treatment plus GP-led maternity ward. Two consultant surgeons and two consultant anaesthetists provide services.

Western Isles Hospital, Stornoway Has 212 beds and offers general surgery, anaesthetics, orthopaedics and a consultant-run maternity unit.

Caithness General Hospital, Wick
Has 86 beds, including a general surgery and general medical ward and a consultant-led maternity service.

Belford Hospital, Fort William
Has 72 beds. It houses a general medical and general surgical ward and a small midwife-led maternity unit.

Lorn and the Islands Hospital, Oban
Offers general medicine and general surgery services, staffed by eight resident consultants, plus a midwife-run maternity unit.


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Related Links

Posted by: Wardog, Buckie on 12:07am Wed 14 May 08


More Good News being 'buried' by Wendy's crisis
Posted by: soloman, Stirling on 12:20am Wed 14 May 08
SNP the Peoples Party!

Vote for Independence.
Posted by: allymax, yuk on 1:10am Wed 14 May 08
COME ON RANGERS !

Win this and millions of pensioners will die happy; regardless.
Posted by: Ian, Dalbeattie on 9:05am Wed 14 May 08
When is something going to be done about the problem facing the Scottish Ambulance Service and their refusal to increase the mileage rate paid to the Volunteer Car Drivers ?They are being paid the same rate for the past seven years despite a huge increase in the cost of running a car. The number of Volunteers who are no longer prepared to provide this service is dropping daily and rural Scotland will be particularly hit be this.
Posted by: spagan, heisker, scotland on 9:37am Wed 14 May 08
After 10 years of uncertainty, these hospitals can now begin to plan long-term to treat and care for their local patients - saving journeys of hundreds of miles.
Excellent news from the Deputy Boss!
Slainte Mhor
Ian - how badly are you guys being reimbursed? What is the rate per mile?
Posted by: Ian, Dalbeattie on 10:57am Wed 14 May 08
Spagan,heisker,
Thank you for taking an interest.
The mileage rate is the same as it has been for the past seven years. It is 36.9p per mile. If it was a fair rate then it is not fair now.
( The Inland Revenue allow other people to claim 45p per mile )
Posted by: TommyK60, Ayr on 11:08am Wed 14 May 08
It is 36.9p per mile. If it was a fair rate then it is not fair now.


That is pathetic, But what else do we expect, people like yourself are undervalued.

Do you get help with your insurance costs because I'm sure they will be higher if you have to tell your Insurance Company what you are using your vehicle for.

Getting back to the original article, I hope that those running the services listen to the people using and working in the hospitals mentioned and don't provide what they think the local community needs.
Posted by: Ian, Dalbeattie on 11:24am Wed 14 May 08
TommyK60,Ayr,
No ,Tommy we get no help with anything. If we are away for more than eight hours we can claim up to £5.00 as a meal allowance, on production of a receipt. We also have to wait weeks before we get reimbursed. For rexample,I took a patient from Dumfries to Aberdeen in the first week in January. It cost me over £60.00 in fuel which i did not get back from Scottish Ambulace Service until the end of february and I was away from home for 13 hours.
Posted by: spagan, heisker, scotland on 1:31pm Wed 14 May 08
Ian
Seems poor - particularly given that you are volunteers. It might be nice if you received the same rate as an MP or an MSP - worth raising this as part of your argument?
I know that even local politicians don't like to be treated the same as their Council staff.
In at least one Council area, Councillors receive the full Inland Revenue allowable rate - however, their staff only receive the "Public Transport Rate" of 9p per mile - if they are covering more than 50 miles each way.
It may be that the Scottish Government has the figures "under review"?
I do some unpaid work for them on a regular basis - with "expenses remunerated". Mileage is paid at 24p/mile for a small engine up to 44p for a large engine. The figure is historic.
Posted by: Ian, Dalbeattie on 3:38pm Wed 14 May 08
Spagan,heisker,
I have written to our MSP to no avail. Did not even get a reply from Ms.Sturgeon. One of her staff said it was up to Scottish Ambulance Service to set the rate. It is all very well reviewing the rate but the day is rapidly approaching when there will be no Volunteers prepared to be treated like this and give the service they provide at the moment.
Posted by: TommyK60, Ayr on 4:13pm Wed 14 May 08
Ian, Dalbeattie wrote:

I have written to our MSP to no avail. Did not even get a reply from Ms.Sturgeon. One of her staff said it was up to Scottish Ambulance Service to set the rate.


That's a bit of a white lie, I work for an organisation which receives funding from SEERAD, our bosses have to get our pay rise approved by SEERAD before they can give it to us, even if our finances can easily afford it, so I can't see them having no input on the subject. Maybe if they suddenly had to find more Ambulance Crews they would wake up to the situation. Maybe someone could raise this issue in the National Press
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use